Last reviewed 26 October 2020
On 24 September 2020, Chancellor Rishi Sunak announced the new Job Support Scheme, aimed at helping businesses retain staff over the coming months and serve as a replacement to the Job Retention (furlough) Scheme. Ben McCarthy, lead researcher and employment law writer at Croner-i, explores key differences between these two schemes below. This article has been updated to incorporate the several changes to the scheme from that which was originally announced.
One could almost be forgiven for getting a foreboding sense of déjà vu in these late September weeks, with the increase in coronavirus cases, and the return of social restrictions, feeling all too familiar to the weeks immediately prior to the original lockdown in March. Back then, with this new virus spreading rapidly and huge numbers of businesses being forced to close, all eyes turned to what assistance the Government was going to provide to help them through this period and retain jobs. This led to the birth of the Job Retention Scheme. When using this scheme, employers place their staff on a period of leave where they do no work, or reduced hours, known as furlough, and the Government funds part of their wages during this time.
Flash forward six months and here we are again, this time ready to welcome a new scheme, the Job Support Scheme. Here, the Government will also partly fund employee wages for hours not worked, but there are some key differences to this that employers need to be familiar with.
How are the schemes similar?
As many businesses can no longer operate as normal due to strict coronavirus restrictions, the aim of both schemes is to help employers keep staff in their roles even if there is less demand for them to do these roles. Both schemes work through the Government funding employee wages, subject to a cap, therefore providing an alternative for companies to explore rather than lay-offs and full redundancies. While the Job Retention Scheme was initially funded entirely by the Government, this changed in August to now be part-funded by employers. From day one, the Job Support Scheme (Open), where employers are permitted to stay open and can offer a minimum threshold of working hours to their employees, will also be funded by both the Government and employers. The Job Support Scheme (Closed), to be used where a business has been required by the Government to close as part of local or national lockdown measures, will be funded by the Government and no employer contribution to wages is required.
It is also important to remember that both are completely optional for businesses; there was and is no expectation upon a company to make use of either of the schemes and it is ultimately down to them how they respond to the challenges of the coronavirus pandemic.
How are the schemes different?
It is first important to understand why the Job Support Scheme has been announced by the Government, and why they have not decided to simply extend the Job Retention Scheme despite numerous calls to do so. Rishi Sunak did provide some answers to this in his speech, outlining that the Government cannot continue to fund jobs that are only still filled due to the Job Retention Scheme. The aim of the JSS (Open) is to now support roles that can continue but simply need some further assistance; in his words, jobs that are “viable”. In short, whilst the Job Retention Scheme was primarily for retaining jobs when the company could not provide work, or had to reduce the work offered, in general the Job Support Scheme is there to help companies which are able to provide a minimum amount of hours unless the business is forced to close due to local or national lockdown measures.
The Job Support Scheme (Open) will require employees to work at least one-fifth (20%) of their normal hours to be eligible for government funds. This is a vast difference from the current rules of the Job Retention Scheme, as here employees can either not work at all or work reduced hours of any duration regardless of the current rate of coronavirus infections in the local area. Under this strand of the Scheme, the Government will fund 66.67% of employee wages attributable to the hours the employee does not work, subject to a maximum of £1,541.75 per month, which again differs from the Job Retention Scheme. The employer must fund the employee’s wages for the hours they work, which is the same as the Job Retention Scheme where flexible furlough was used. The employers will also pay 5% of wages attributable to unworked hours, to a maximum of £125 per month.
In scenarios where businesses are forced to close, the Job Support Scheme (Closed) will provide two-thirds (67%) of employee wage costs, to a maximum of £2,083.33 per month, despite the employee not working at all. Whilst this does bear some similarities to the Job Retention Scheme, in that employees will not have to work at all to benefit from it, there are still fundamental differences. This additional support is only being provided in the specific circumstance of a lockdown forcing business closure; it cannot be used if the business can remain open. Furthermore, the amount provided by the Government is still less than what was previously offered under the Job Retention Scheme.
The immense cost of the Job Retention Scheme has likely influenced the decision to restrict access to the Job Support Scheme. When it was originally introduced, the Job Retention Scheme was open to any business, regardless of size or sector. The Job Support Scheme is a little different. While any small to medium-sized enterprise (SME) will be able to make use of it, larger businesses (those with 250 or more employees) will only be able to do so if they can show that their turnover has stayed the same or dropped.
As the Job Support Scheme is designed to protect jobs, it is also not surprising to note that employees on the scheme cannot be given notice of redundancy, something that was not prohibited for those furloughed under the Job Retention Scheme. This applies in both the Open and Closed versions of the Scheme.
What about the Job Retention Bonus?
Designed as another way of encouraging employers to retain their staff, employers who retain previously furloughed employees until at least 31 January 2021 will receive £1000 for each employee, subject to further eligibility. One thing that Rishi Sunak has made clear is that use of the Job Support Scheme will not impact on this; companies that reduce employee hours to make use of the Job Support Scheme, or cannot provide any work because of an enforced closure, will still be able to later claim the Job Retention Bonus provided the Bonus scheme’s criteria are met.