Last reviewed 8 September 2020
Christopher Wagner and Richard Pelly of Pellys Transport & Regulatory Law summarise the recent changes to the EU Drivers’ Hours rules.
First and foremost, and for the avoidance of any doubt or potential for misunderstanding: despite Brexit, the EU Drivers’ Hours Regulations continue to apply in the UK, and this is certainly expected to remain the case after the transition period ends on 31 December 2020.
As the regulations are updated, the amended law will also apply in the UK. EU Regulation 2020/1054, which amends EC Regulation 561/2006 (the key existing Drivers’ Hours Regulation) was ratified by the European Parliament and Council on 15 July 2020, and came into effect in the UK on 20 August 2020.
The amended rules — key changes
The new changes are very likely to affect most operators in one way or another — and while more of the changes apply directly to HGV operators, PSV operators should certainly take note. New provisions relate to rests and breaks for journeys involving transport by ferry or rail, a new rule on driving breaks for double-manned journeys as well as a derogation allowing daily and weekly driving time to be exceeded in certain exceptional circumstances.
Suitable accommodation for overnight rests
There has long been debate surrounding the suitability of vehicles for drivers to take weekly rest breaks, and the rules have finally been changed to include an outright ban on drivers taking weekly rest breaks in vehicles. The amended regulations specifically state that weekly rest breaks should be taken in “suitable, gender-friendly accommodation with adequate sleeping and sanitary facilities” — and crucially, that the employer of the driver should pay for these facilities. It is anticipated that the courts will seek to construe the meaning of the term “employer” widely.
Rests and breaks on ferry or rail journeys
The existing provision in relation to drivers taking daily rest periods when they are accompanying a vehicle which is being transported by ferry or train has been amended to provide for reduced weekly rest periods (in addition to the existing provision relating to daily rests) as long as the journey is scheduled for more than eight hours. The amendment also broadens the specification of sleeping facilities which must be available to drivers to include a sleeper cabin (rather than specifically and only to a bunk or couchette). It remains the case that rest cannot be interrupted more than twice, and that those interruptions cannot exceed a total of one hour. The relevant text of the now-amended Article 9 is as follows, with the new sections highlighted:
“…where a driver accompanies a vehicle which is transported by ferry or train and takes a regular daily rest period or reduced weekly rest period that period may be interrupted not more than twice by other activities not exceeding one hour in total. During that regular daily rest or reduced weekly rest period, the driver shall have access to a sleeper cabin, bunk or couchette at their disposal”.
Complete records of other work
In a more subtle amendment, the provision relating to the requirement to record as other work any time spent carrying out non-driving activities — as well as to record all periods of availability — has been tightened, with the effect that drivers must ensure that they keep complete records of all other work (including periods of availability). Records should be kept using record sheets, digital tachograph printouts, or tachograph manual entries.
On double or multi-manned journeys, drivers are now permitted to take 45-minute breaks in a vehicle while it is being driven by another driver, provided that the driver taking the break is not involved in assisting the driver driving the vehicle (for example, by map-reading). In addition, for a break to be valid, the driver cannot be engaged in any other work — so the driver taking a break will not be in a position to assist with passengers during the period of the break.
Returning home every four weeks
Although rare for passenger tours to exceed four weeks, both PSV and haulage operators should take note: there is a new rule requiring transport undertakings to schedule work in a way which enables all drivers to return to the operating centre at which they are normally based at least once within each period of four consecutive weeks, in order that they can take at least one regular weekly rest period (or a longer period if compensatory rest is due) at their place of residence. Transport undertakings are required to retain documents evidencing how they meet these obligations.
EU to provide list of safe parking areas
Another changes requires the European Commission itself to ensure that information relating to safe and secure parking areas is easily accessible to drivers, and the EC will publish and maintain a list (which will be available on an official website) of certified parking places.
Extending daily or weekly driving time to get home
Arguably the most “game changing” amendments are new provisions permitting the extension of daily and weekly driving time in exceptional circumstances, in order to allow drivers to reach their employer’s operating centre or their home before taking a weekly rest period.
The provisions are similar to those which already exist to allow drivers to exceed 4.5 hours’ driving before taking a break in exceptional circumstances. As with the existing Article 12 exemption, drivers may only take advantage of the new provisions if there is no risk that road safety would be jeopardised by them doing so.
The two versions of the derogation are the following.
Drivers may exceed the daily and weekly driving time by up to one hour in order to reach the operating centre or their place of residence to take a weekly rest.
Drivers may exceed the daily and weekly driving time by up to two hours in the same circumstances, provided that they have taken an uninterrupted break of 30 minutes immediately prior to any additional driving.
Where drivers do need to avail themselves of this derogation, they will need to compensate by adding an equivalent period of rest with any other rest period by the end of the third week after the week in question.
Advice for Operators
As with any change in the law, the first step is for operators to ensure that they are familiar with the changes and take a view quickly on how those changes will affect them and what, if any, operational systems need to be revised.
The following points are key to ensuring drivers’ hours and tachograph compliance.
Make sure that all relevant staff have a complete understanding of the rules and their application.
Ensure proper scheduling so that work can be completed lawfully.
Have in place a system for regular downloads of vehicle and driver data (and/or the review of analogue charts).
Have in place a reliable and up-to-date system for tachograph analysis (and run the analysis regularly).
Carry out thorough responsive investigations on reported infringements and take meaningful and proportionate action to non-compliance whether by drivers and/or the traffic office.